🔗 Affiliate Disclosure: We earn small commissions from Amazon purchases made through our links at no extra cost to you. This helps fund our independent testing lab. We only recommend products we've actually tested and believe in.
Brother HL-L2350DW (Best Overall)
✅ Pros
- Very low running costs
- Fast printing speed
- Reliable duplex printing
- Easy wireless setup
❌ Cons
- Monochrome only
- No scanning function
Canon PIXMA TR4720 (Best All-in-One)
✅ Pros
- Complete office functions
- Good photo quality
- Compact design
- Affordable upfront cost
❌ Cons
- Higher ink costs
- Slower printing speed
Epson EcoTank ET-2850 (Lowest Cost)
✅ Pros
- Extremely low operating costs
- Massive ink capacity
- No cartridges to replace
- Great for high volume
❌ Cons
- Higher upfront cost
- Ink can dry out if unused
Printer Comparison
| Model | Price | Type | Cost per Page | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brother HL-L2350DW | $149-199 | Laser | 2.8¢ | Document printing |
| Canon PIXMA TR4720 | $89-129 | Inkjet | 5-12¢ | Light office use |
| Epson EcoTank ET-2850 | $249-299 | Supertank | 0.3-1¢ | High volume printing |
True Cost Calculator
Most people focus only on upfront costs, but operating expenses matter more over time.
Example: 2,000 pages per year
- Brother Laser: $199 printer + $56 running costs = $255 total first year
- Canon Inkjet: $129 printer + $240 running costs = $369 total first year
- Epson EcoTank: $299 printer + $6 running costs = $305 total first year
Printer Buying Guide
Choose Based on Your Needs:
- Document-only printing: Laser printer for speed and low costs
- Photos + documents: All-in-one inkjet for versatility
- High volume (500+ pages/month): EcoTank or laser for economics
- Occasional use: Basic inkjet to avoid dried ink issues
- Small business: Laser with duplex and wireless features
Red Flags to Avoid:
- Printers with proprietary ink cartridges only
- Models with poor wireless connectivity reviews
- Inkjet printers if you print infrequently (ink dries out)
- Choosing based on upfront cost alone
🛒 Ready to Buy? Verified Purchase Links
✓ Best current pricing (we track deals daily)
✓ Small commission helps fund our testing lab
✓ Same price as buying direct (Amazon price matching)
Need Printer Advice?
We test printers for 6 months in real office conditions. Get personalized recommendations.
Get Expert HelpBrother HL-L2350DW Complete Review
What We Tested
We ran this printer through 6 months of daily office use, printing over 3,000 pages including reports, invoices, and documents.
Print Quality Results:
- Text Documents: Crisp, professional quality at 600x600 DPI
- Graphics: Clean lines and solid fills, excellent for charts
- Small Text: Readable down to 8pt font size
- Speed Test: Consistently achieved 30-32 ppm in normal mode
Long-term Performance
After 3,000 pages:
- Reliability: Zero paper jams during testing period
- Toner Efficiency: Original cartridge lasted 2,600 pages
- WiFi Connectivity: Maintained stable connection throughout
- Duplex Function: Worked flawlessly with no alignment issues
- Operating Cost: Averaged 2.8¢ per page including electricity
Real-World Testing Scenarios
Heavy Document Day
200 pages of mixed documents in 2 hours. Printer maintained speed and quality throughout. No overheating or slowdown.
Wireless Printing
Printed from 5 different devices simultaneously. Connection remained stable with minimal queue delays.
Duplex Reliability
500 double-sided prints with various paper weights. Zero misfeeds or alignment problems.
Who Should Buy This Printer
Perfect for: Small offices, home businesses, and anyone who primarily prints text documents and needs reliable, cost-effective operation.
Skip if: You need color printing or scanning functions. This is a dedicated monochrome laser printer.
Canon PIXMA TR4720 Complete Review
All-in-One Performance Testing
We tested all functions extensively: printing, scanning, copying, and fax capabilities over 4 months of mixed office use.
Print Quality Results:
- Text Documents: Sharp black text, minimal bleeding
- Photos: Good color accuracy on photo paper
- Mixed Documents: Clean graphics and readable text
- Speed: 8.8 ppm for text, 4.4 ppm for photos
Scanning & Copy Quality
Scanner Performance:
- Resolution: Up to 1200x2400 DPI optical
- Color Accuracy: Excellent reproduction of documents
- ADF Function: Handles up to 20 sheets reliably
- Copy Speed: 7.7 cpm for black, 4.0 cpm for color
- Mobile Scanning: Canon PRINT app works seamlessly
Ink Cost Analysis
Real Operating Costs After 1,200 Pages:
5.2¢ per page average
12.8¢ per page average
28¢ per 4x6 photo
Tip: Use XL cartridges and compatible inks to reduce costs by 40-60%
Best Use Cases
Ideal for: Home offices needing versatile functions, small businesses with moderate printing needs, and users who occasionally print photos.
Consider alternatives if: You print more than 500 pages monthly or need faster print speeds for business use.
Epson EcoTank ET-2850 Complete Review
Tank System Performance
We tested the EcoTank system through one complete ink refill cycle, tracking exactly 4,500 pages of mixed printing.
Ink Efficiency Results:
- Black Ink Yield: 4,500 pages exactly as advertised
- Color Ink Yield: 7,500 pages (photo quality mode)
- Refill Process: Simple, mess-free with keyed bottles
- Print Quality: Maintained consistency throughout tank
Cost Breakdown Analysis
True Operating Costs:
- Black Text: 0.3¢ per page (ink only)
- Color Documents: 1.0¢ per page average
- Photo Prints: 3.2¢ per 4x6 photo
- Electricity: ~$0.02 per 100 pages
- Paper: Primary ongoing expense
Volume Testing Results
High-Volume Day
Printed 300 pages continuously. No quality degradation or overheating. Slower than laser but reliable.
Idle Period Test
Left unused for 3 weeks. First prints required 2-3 cleaning cycles to restore quality.
Mixed Media
Tested with various paper types: plain, photo, cardstock. Excellent versatility across all media.
Economic Break-Even Analysis
When EcoTank Makes Financial Sense:
Break-even vs. Canon TR4720: After 2,100 pages (about 18 months for typical office)
Pays for itself in 6-8 months
May never break even due to ink drying
Who Should Choose EcoTank
Perfect for: High-volume users, photo enthusiasts, small businesses with consistent printing needs above 200 pages monthly.
Skip if: You print less than 100 pages monthly, need fast printing speeds, or prefer the simplicity of cartridges.